Why Target Stock Level Not Safety Inventory is the Right Focus

Executive Summary

  • Safety stock is set in practice far differently than how it is explained in books.
  • To understand safety stock it is helpful to consider the target stock level.
  • Safety stock, target stock level is connected to inventory optimization and multi echelon.

Introduction

Safety inventory or safety stock is widely misunderstood and with many problems in setting the value logically. You will learn how it is set and the relationship to the target stocking level.

Overfocus on Safety Inventory

I have always found the many supply chain professionals and executives have been far too focused on safety inventory. Safety inventory is just that, the inventory that is carried to deal with unforeseen events. It could just as easily be called variability stock, or the stock that is held to account for variability in the supply chain. The exact formula is listed in this article. However, for this article, it’s merely necessary to consider that safety stock is the component of the total stocking level which is designed to account for variability in supply and demand.

The best way to think of safety stock is that at a high level it has three inputs:

Safety Stock = Initial Stocking Level + Supply Variability + Demand Variability

How Safety Inventory is Often Set In Practice

Safety inventory can be calculated with a safety inventory formula, which adjusts with changes in the variability of supply and demand, which is called dynamic safety stock. It can also be set manually. Also, safety stock can be calculated inside of the ERP or planning system, or externally and imported (hard-coded) into the system.

Most companies do not have dynamic safety inventory enabled, and safety stock is usually updated manually with a variety of calculation techniques.

The result of this is that most companies are not taking advantage of their system’s ability (regardless of the supply planning method employed or the particular vendor) to auto-adjust safety stock. This places an extra load on the supply planning organization because it is another parameter that must be actively managed.

Accounting for Variability in Non Inventory Optimization Supply Planning Applications

Unknown to a large contingent of companies that are running the older supply planning methods (MRP/DRP, Heuristic, Cost Optimization and Allocation), safety inventory is the only factor that accounts for variability in the supply chain from the inventory perspective.  It is also the only place where service level is accounted for, for three of the four methods of supply planning listed above. (MRP/DRP, Heuristic, and Allocation). Cost optimization can account for service goals, but only in an indirect manner. A cost optimizer, by comparison, has only the ability to set the service component based upon penalty costs. This is a much more blunt instrument for connecting the service level to the language that the optimizer understands. This is because the penalty cost only has to mean to the cost optimizer about other costs that are included in the system.

This is a major weakness of cost optimization systems. In fact, the best way for a company to proceed in determining if cost optimization is the best choice for them is to first internally agree on all the costs that will drive the optimizer. If they cannot internally drive to this agreement, then cost optimization is not a good choice for them, even if their primary supply chain objective is to minimize costs. This addresses an issue that is often missed. A method selected must not only be the right fit for the business requirements but must also fit with the company’s ability to implemented the chosen method.

Inventory optimization and multi-echelon (MEIO) have a superior approach to setting the target stock level which is still not widely understood. MEIO applications can at a very fine level of detail set the target stock level based upon service levels that are applied at either the most disaggregated (product location) or higher levels of aggregation, depending of course on the particular vendor selected.

Target Stock Level and Safety Stock in MEIO Applications

MEIO systems also have and calculate safety stock. However, they have the ability to set the target stock level or TSL at the most accurate and sophisticated way that is currently available in the software. This class of application uses the service level to set both the safety stock and the target stock level.

The way inventory optimization calculates safety stock is in most cases identical to the safety stock functionality with heuristic or cost-based optimization supply planning application calculates safety stock. The main functionality in inventory optimization goes towards the calculation of the initial stocking level or target stock level.

TSLorSS

Understanding the Distinction between Target Stock Level and Safety Stock

When I have the conversation regarding MEIO and its relationship to safety inventory, the person I am speaking with will sometimes propose that he or she agrees with me in principle, but then will add,

However, inventory optimization does improve safety stock.

To simply correlate the two is to miss the point of inventory optimization. Inventory optimization is bigger than safety stock.

  • Dynamic safety stock is a simple calculation that is performed at a product-location combination, while inventory optimization is a set of mathematics that encompasses the entire supply network and meets service level targets by distributing inventory to every product location optimally.
  • It’s the difference between a formula that can be calculated in a single cell of a spreadsheet (safety stock) and a set of mathematics so complex that few people understand what it does. That’s why it is incorrect to say that inventory optimization is focused on safety stock.

While safety stock does not need to be optimized, it should always be dynamic—that is, it should flex with the variability in supply and demand. Therefore, inventory optimization and safety stock are independent of one another. A company can implement dynamic safety stock without implementing inventory optimization, and vice versa.

The Right Focus

  • Safety inventory is critical, but it should never be the primary focus within the supply planning organization.
  • It should be auto-calculated and left to the system to control. If it isn’t, and if the supply planning organization is spending much time discussing its safety stock, then it is wasting time because the formula for dynamic safety stock is correct and extensively tested.

What is to be questioned is the quality of the lead time variability or demand variability, which the dynamic safety stock formula uses to calculate safety inventory. These are questions related to improving the inputs to the formula, which is a different topic. Instead, target stock levels at a product location should be the focus.

MEIO applications allow direct control over the TSL because the objective function of the optimizer is to minimize inventory vs. service level or to maximize service level based upon inventory.

Search Our Other Supply Chain Optimization Content

Brightwork Explorer for Service Level & Stock Management

Faster and More Straightforward Approach than Inventory Optimization

Inventory optimization started with a bang but failed to live up to the hype that was built up for it. Inventory optimization software is normally overly complex and while the idea is right, successes with inventory optimization are rare.

After seeing many failed inventory optimization projects we developed a simpler and less invasive way of modeling service levels and inventory. The Brightwork Explorer is free to access until it sees “serious usage” and is free for academics and students. Select the image below for more details.

References

MEIO Book

What is MEIO?

This book explains the emerging technology of inventory optimization and multi-echelon (MEIO) supply planning. The book takes a complex subject and effectively communicates what MEIO is about in plain English terms. This is the only book currently available that describes MEIO for practitioners, rather for mathematicians or academics.

The Interaction with Service Levels

The this book explains how inventory optimization allows the entire supply plan to be controlled with service levels, and how multi-echelon technology answers the question of where to locate inventory in the supply network.
This is the only book on inventory optimization and multi echelon planning which compares how different best of breed vendors apply MEIO technology to their products. It also explains why this technology is so important for supply planning and why companies should be actively investigating this method.
The book moves smoothly between concepts to screen shots and descriptions of how the screens are configured and used. This provides the reader with some of the most intriguing areas of functionality within a variety of applications.
Chapters
  • Chapter 1: Introduction
  • Chapter 2: Where Inventory Optimization and Multi-Echelon Planning
  • Fit within the Supply Chain Planning Footprint
  • Chapter 3: Inventory Optimization Explained
  • Chapter 4: Multi-Echelon Planning Explained
  • Chapter 5: How Inventory Optimization and Multi-Echelon Work
  • Together to Optimize the Supply Plan
  • Chapter 6: MEIO Versus Cost Optimization
  • Chapter 7: MEIO and Simulation
  • Chapter 8: MEIO and Service Level Agreements
  • Chapter 9: How MEIO is Different from APS and MRP/DRP
  • Chapter 10: Conclusion
  • References
  • Vendor Acknowledgements and Profiles
  • Author Profile
  • Abbreviations
  • Links in the Book
  • Appendix A: MEIO Visibility and Analytics
  • Appendix B: The History of Development of MEIO Versus MRP/DRP