How to Best Understand SAP’s Use of Indirect Access to Drive HANA Sales

Executive Summary

  • Indirect Access and Databases
  • What is Happening in the Field with HANA and Indirect Access?
  • Giving in Too Easily to SAP’s Indirect Access Claims


Indirect access is normally focused on applications and the best-known application of indirect access by SAP. And if you read articles on the topic of indirect access, they primarily cover applications. However, HANA has as many indirect access liabilities as does SAP’s applications. This is covered in the article SAP Indirect Access and the HANA Police.

What is Happening in the Field with HANA and Indirect Access?

So the question is, what is happening with HANA and indirect access.

Well, quite under the radar, SAP is effectively using indirect access claims with HANA in two ways:

Using SAP Application Indirect Access to Sell HANA

SAP is using indirect access claims related to its applications to drive customers to HANA. The customer has a choice of what to purchase, but when the customer comes to the negotiation table, the SAP account executive will normally guide the customer into settling the indirect access claim by purchasing either S/4HANA or HANA. I have reports of tens of millions of dollars of indirect access claims by SAP. These claims are brought, just as with an indirect access claim designed to block a purchase of application from a competitive vendor, after the company has made the decision to purchase a competitive application. This leads to company move from one database vendor they had already selected to another database vendor, or to SAP.

Enforcing Indirect Access on a Preexisting HANA Install

Once HANA is sold, the most frequent use of indirect access is to get more from the customer than they intended to pay for HANA. This can be accomplished in multiple ways. One is to simply undersize the HANA database, something will automatically happen if SAP’s assumptions regarding sizing are followed. This will cause the customer to have to go back and buy more HANA GB licenses, and after the decision to go with HANA has already been made. Secondly, SAP uses both a runtime license and indirect access to audit customers and come back later for more money. The main objective of the account executive is to simply get HANA sold. After it is sold, SAP has a multitude of ways of coming back later to charge for more.

There are several problems with being forced into purchase HANA however, and one is that HANA is sold on exaggerated claims as is covered in the article When Articles Exaggerate SAP HANA’s Benefits. And by force fitting HANA into areas that is not naturally a good fit, the likelihood of failure increases as is covered in the article Is HANA the Right for the EDW?

Giving in Too Easily to SAP’s Indirect Access Claims

Companies are being beaten by SAP and acquiescing to their demands on indirect access far too quickly, which brings up all manner of future liabilities. Part of this has to do with SAP customers being too willing to not take indirect access seriously and to prepare before receiving an indirect access claim.

Amazingly, the majority of SAP customers still don’t use SAM software, which is a first step to protecting oneself against indirect access claims, a topic which is covered in the article, Taking a Multidimensional Approach to SAP Indirect Access.


Customers should consider very careful about being either pushed into HANA through an indirect access claim by SAP and be aware of the indirect access liabilities of HANA itself. These are liabilities that no other database vendors have as no other database vendor claims Type 2 indirect access.

Brightwork Disclosure

Financial Bias Disclosure

This article and no other article on the Brightwork website is paid for by a software vendor, including Oracle and SAP. Brightwork does offer competitive intelligence work to vendors as part of its business, but no published research or articles are written with any financial consideration. As part of Brightwork’s commitment to publishing independent, unbiased research, the company’s business model is driven by consulting services; no paid media placements are accepted.

HANA & S/4HANA Question Box

  • Have Questions About S/4HANA & HANA?

    It is difficult for most companies to make improvements in S/4HANA and HANA without outside advice. And it is close to impossible to get honest S/4HANA and HANA advice from large consulting companies. We offer remote unbiased multi-dimension S/4HANA and HANA support.

    Just fill out the form below and we'll be in touch.


Risk Estimation and Calculation

Risk Estimation and Calculation

See our free project risk estimators that are available per application. The provide a method of risk analysis that is not available from other sources.